The Bagel Exchange

Design Your Own Lunch - DYO Lunch

Choose bagel, meat, cheese, toasting options, toppings and dressing.

$9.40 · Customizable

New York's Finest #1- Smoked Salmon (LOX)

Smoked Salmon, plain cream cheese, capers and red onions, served on an everything bagel.

$10.30 · Customizable

NYPD Blue #2-Chicken, Ham and Cheese Melt

Heated chicken ham and swiss topped with mayo, lettuce & tomato served on multi-grain bagel.

$9.40 · Customizable

The Chief #3 : Pastrami Reuben

A reuben with hot pastrami, melted swiss cheese, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing on a pumpernickel bagel.

$9.90 · Customizable

Turkey Reuben - On A Pumpernickel Bagel

A reuben with hot turkey, melted swiss cheese, sauerkraut, & thousand island dressing served on a pumpernickel bagel.

$9.90 · Customizable

The Inspector #4-Spicy Chicken

Boar's head spicy buffalo chicken breast and provolone with lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing served on a sun dried tomato bagel.

$9.40 · Customizable

The Commander #5-Roast Beef

Thinly sliced boar's head roast beef with lettuce, tomato, mayo and horseradish dressing served on a cheddar bagel.

$9.90 · Customizable

The BLT #6 Captain with Bacon

A bacon, lettuce & tomato sandwich topped with mayo and served on a multi-grain bagel.

$8.80 · Customizable

The Lieutenant #7 Club with Bacon

A sesame bagel with black forest ham, smoked turkey & crisp bacon strips, topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion and honey mustard dressing.

$9.40 · Customizable

The Sergeant #8-Turkey and Provolone

Smoked turkey and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayo served on an onion bagel.

$9.40 · Customizable

The Detective #9-Ham and Swiss

Black forest ham and swiss cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion, & deli dressing served on a sesame bagel.

$9.40 · Customizable

The Gangsta #9 3/4-italian Meats, Ham And Provolone

Black forest ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion and deli dressing served on an everything bagel.

$9.90 · Customizable

Turkey Gangsta #9 7/8-italian Meats, Turkey and Provolone

Turkey, salami, pepperoni, & provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, red onion and deli dressing served on an everything bagel.

$9.90 · Customizable

The Patrolman #10-Chicken Salad

Gourmet chicken salad with lettuce, tomato, and red onion served on a multi-grain bagel.

$9.40 · Customizable

The Vegetarian #11 Sandwich with Veggie Spread (Vclt)

V.L.T.- vegetable cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, and cucumbers served on a multi-grain bagel.

$7.70 · Customizable

The Vegan #12 Cadet (Clto) :Without Cheese

Vegan. L.T.O.- spicy mustard, lettuce, tomato, red onion and cucumbers served on a multi-grain bagel.

$7.20 · Customizable

The Security Officer #13-Egg Salad

Egg Salad on a Multi-grain bagel with lettuce, tomato, and red onion.

$7.70 · Customizable

Sliced Bagel Topped With Spread

Toasting options with cream cheese, butter or jelly for additional cost. Select bagel and scroll down for toppings. For "Bagged whole bagel(s)" scroll to bakery tab below.

$1.50 · Customizable

Spread On The Side Of A Sliced Bagel Or Dry without /With Spread

Topping of your choice for additional cost.

$1.50 · Customizable

Scrambled Egg on a Bagel

We use two eggs on each sandwich. Scroll completely down after selection to add meats and cheese for additional costs.

$4.40 · Customizable

Bagel with Breakfast Meat and Or Cheese Only (Without Eggs)

Add-ons like cream cheese, jelly, or bacon, etc. All deli meats selected in this section will be heated. This section does not offer lunch portions of deli meat.

$1.50 · Customizable

Ny's Finest #1 Smoked Salmon Sandwich (Lox)

Smoked salmon, capers, red onions on an everything bagel.

$9.40 · Customizable

Provolone Pizza Bagel Express Lunch Kit

4 bagels (2 cheddar, 2 plain) provolone cheese and sauce.

$18.70 · Customizable

Pepperoni And Provolone Pizza Express Bagel Lunch Kit

4 bagels (2 cheddar, 2 plain) provolone cheese, thin sliced pepperoni and sauce.

$21.60 · Customizable

Strom Bagel Express Lunch Kit

4 bagels (2 sundried tom and 2 pl) provolone cheese, thin sliced pepperoni and sauce.

$23.80 · Customizable

American (Club) Deli Express Bagel Lunch Kit

4 bagels (ched, ses, et, pl) turkey, ham, american cheese, toppings, mayo and mustard.

$22.00 · Customizable

German (Reuben) Deli Express Bagel Lunch Kit

4 bagels ( et, pump, mg, pl) pastrami, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, thousand island and spicy mustard.

$23.10 · Customizable

Irish (Roast beef) Deli Express Bagel Lunch Kit

4 bagels (ched, jal ch, et, pl) roast beef, toppings, mayo and horse radish.

$23.10 · Customizable

Italian (9 3/4) Deli Express Bagel Lunch Kit

4 bagels (ched, ses, et, pl) salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone cheese, toppings and deli dressing.

$24.20 · Customizable

French (Smoked Salmon) Deli Express Bagel Lunch Kit

4 bagels (2 et, mg, sesame) smoked salmon, capers, cream cheese, red onion and tomato.

$31.90 · Customizable

Cinnamon Buns

Delicious cinnamon buns served with or without icing.

Price varies · Customizable

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Christie's cookie made with real butter baked in our store.

Price varies · Customizable

Scones

Choose from three delicious flavors baked in our shop; "Apple cinnamon", "Blueberry" or "Raspberry-white chocolate chip".

Price varies · Customizable

Fresh Baked Muffins

Choose from two delicious flavors baked in the store; blueberry or cappuccino-chocolate chunk.

Price varies · Customizable

Yogurt filled Muffins

Choose from two delicious flavors; blueberry lemon filled or strawberry rhubarb filled muffins.

Price varies · Customizable

Stern's Small Black and White Cookie

Individually packaged made in brooklyn.

$1.70

Classic Italian Rainbow Cookie 2 oz.

Individual package of 3 made in islip, ny by original cake bites only 270 calories.

$2.50

Dozen Take Home Bagels

Choose twelve delicious whole bagels bagged to go, add a container of cream cheese for additional cost; for multiple dozens select add to cart after each 12 are selected choose single bagged whole bagels if lower quantity is desired.

$15.40 · Customizable

Whole Take Home Bagel(S)

Choose individual whole bagels bagged to go. For bagels with toasting options: dry or with spreads, meats or eggs scroll down to breakfast items tab.

$1.50 · Customizable

Cream Cheeses Containers

2 oz. Enough for one bagel, 4 oz. Enough for at least 2 bagels, 8 oz enough for at least 4 bagels, and 12 oz enough for at least 6 bagels.

Price varies · Customizable

Bagel Chips

In store made garlic bagel chips great with hummus, veggie cream cheese and more.

$2.20

Pickle Spears

Boar's head garlic deli pickle pre-sliced spears (no longer available as whole pickles.)

Price varies · Customizable

Chips

$1.70 · Customizable

Antipasto Salad

Tri-color rotini pasta with cucumber, olives, tomatoes and pepperoni in an italian dressing.

Price varies · Customizable

Container of Chicken Salad

Shredded chicken, mayo, celery, salt, pepper, seasoned bread crumbs, diced poultry.

Price varies · Customizable

Container of Egg Salad

Mixed hard boiled eggs, mayo, salt and pepper.

Price varies · Customizable

Breakfast Side Order

Bacon, sausage or deli meat etc. On a plate for additional cost.

$1.10 · Customizable

Scrambled Eggs Side

Price varies · Customizable

Garden Salad

Spring mix with cucumber, tomato, red onion and cheddar cheese. Large garden salad comes with 4 oz side of dressing & side salad comes with a 2 oz side of dressing.

$6.60 · Customizable

Side Salad

Spring mix with cucumber, tomato, red onion and cheddar cheese. Large garden salad comes with 4 oz side of dressing & side salad comes with a 2 oz side of dressing.

$3.60 · Customizable

Hot Soup

Price varies · Customizable

Smoked Salmon Pre-Sliced

Price varies · Customizable

Tavern Ham

Boar's Head brand sliced to order.

Price varies · Customizable

Smoked Turkey

Boar's head mesquite wood smoked.

Price varies · Customizable

Classic Chicken Breast

Boar's head golden classic oven roasted 42% lower sodium.

Price varies · Customizable

Spicy Chicken Breast

Boar's head blazing buffalo style roasted chicken breast.

Price varies · Customizable

Pastrami

Boar's head pastrami.

Price varies · Customizable

Roast Beef

Boar's head london broil cap-off top round oven roasted beef.

Price varies · Customizable

Boar's Head Salami

Price varies · Customizable

Boar's Head Pepperoni

Price varies · Customizable

Provolone Cheese

Boar's head provolone cheese.

Price varies · Customizable

American Cheese

Boar's head american cheese (yellow).

Price varies · Customizable

Swiss Cheese

Boar's head imported Switzerland swiss cheese.

Price varies · Customizable

Coffee

By the cup or gallon.

Price varies · Customizable

Cappuccino Coffee

Keurig cafe escapes.

Price varies · Customizable

Latte Coffee with Froth

Gevalia 2-step Keurig pods includes froth.

Price varies · Customizable

Dasani

20 ounce water bottle.

$1.70

Bottled Beverages

Sodas, teas and sports drinks in plastic bottles unless specified.

$1.70 · Customizable

100% Juice Bottles

$2.80 · Customizable

Bottled Iced Coffee

Dunkin' donuts brand available in two flavors.

Price varies · Customizable

Pre-Sweetened Iced Coffee

Pre-sweetned and mixed with cream you may add whipped cream if you like.

$3.30 · Customizable

Sweet Tea or Unsweet Tea

By the cup or Gallon with cups.

Price varies · Customizable

Fountain Beverage

Price varies · Customizable

Horizon Organic Milk

Individual milk box with small straw: choose flavors below.

$2.50 · Customizable

Hot Chocolate

With or without whipped cream.

Price varies · Customizable

Kids Skinny Ham and American Cheese Melt

A skinny plain bagel with a children's portion of heated ham & melted american cheese.

$4.40 · Customizable

Kids Skinny Turkey & Provolone Cheese Melt

A skinny plain bagel with a children's portion of heated turkey and melted provolone cheese.

$4.40 · Customizable

Build Your Own Skinny PB and J

A Skinny plain bagel with a side of peanut butter and a side of grape or strawberry jelly.

$4.40 · Customizable

Kid Skinny Bagel With A Single Scrambled Egg

A skinny bagel of your choice with a single scrambled egg. Not the same as our regular egg sandwich.

$3.20 · Customizable

Bagel With (Spreads On Side)

Topping of your choice or add cheese for additional cost.

$1.50 · Customizable

Scrambled Eggs on a plate

Add bacon, sausage, or heated deli meat, for additional cost.

$3.30 · Customizable

Kids Side Order

Bacon, sausage, or deli meat, etc. On a plate for additional cost.

$1.10 · Customizable

Pack of Trident Mint Gum

$2.80

Full Size Candy Bar

Hershey's full size candy bars & other treats.

$1.70 · Customizable

Bagel Exchange Logo Coffee Mug

Stainless steel hand wash campfire mug with lid.

$16.50

Bagel Exchange Logo Hat

Baseball cap with b.E. Logo on it.

$11.00